Ratings and reviews
Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse Photos
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse Reviews
Edit: They reached out to me immediately and fixed the issue. The extra charge was reversed. Thank you Sally!
Good bar. Bacardi tastes just like I remember. Taco Thursday was good. We had very good steak and ground beef tacos. The salsa is good. We plan to go back for Bison Burgers.
Fantastic jambalaya, good burgers. Staff fantastic. Owner works the tables. Very rustic cabin style location.
Casual atmosphere with friendly service and amazing food!! Highly recommend.....we have another basketball tournament in Waukesha, 20 minutes away, next weekend and I'm already making plans to relax here after!!!
Good food and drinks without braking the bank...cool place to hit on a easy night out. "Must haves" are the burgers and tacos!
Great food and service . Fresh salsa and chips on Thursday! Great fun atmosphere. You should definitely try it.
This place has become our favorite neighborhood bar. Tacos are the best anywhere around - Thursdays you are lucky to find a seat but the secret is sundays they offer similar taco deals but with added sides. Even with how busy it is, the food always comes out fast and tastes delicious. The meat is always very tender and flavorful. I'd recommend ordering a side of guac, made in house fresh. Chips and salsa are free! Besides the tacos, i havent had a bad meal here - burgers especially are glod. Drinks are great and they are constantly adding new alcohol and brands I havent heard of which are consistently good. Service is prompt and attentive and the owners are responsive. It's worth multiple visits.
Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse
If you're seeking a vibrant dining experience with an eclectic vibe and a menu brimming with flavorful options, look no further than Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse. Nestled at 18540 W National Ave, New Berlin, WI 53146, this beloved roadhouse has earned its spot as a local gem. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you'll discover why it remains a favorite for foodies and fun-seekers alike.
A Thriving Spot for Food and Fun
The hallmark of Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse is its perfect blend of casual comfort and lively energy. This isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a destination. From the moment you step through the doors, you're greeted by a warm atmosphere that perfectly complements its rustic decor. The menu boasts a variety of crowd-pleasers, including juicy burgers, perfectly cooked steaks, and hearty sandwiches. For those looking for lighter fare, their salads and seafood options are equally impressive.
On weekends, the place truly comes alive with live music performances that transform it into a hotspot for locals and visitors alike. Mustang Shelly's isn’t just about the food; it’s about the full experience.
Diverse Menu to Satisfy Every Craving
The heart of any dining establishment is its menu, and Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse doesn't disappoint. Their offerings cater to a wide range of tastes, ensuring there's something for everyone. Start your meal with an order of their signature appetizers, like crispy onion rings or loaded potato skins, perfect for sharing with friends.
Entrées feature robust options like the classic Roadhouse Burger, topped with melty cheese and fresh toppings, or the tender BBQ ribs glazed with a tangy sauce. For those seeking comfort food, the homemade mac and cheese or chicken pot pie delivers nostalgic flavors with every bite. Don’t forget to ask about the daily specials—they often include seasonal dishes crafted with fresh, local ingredients.
Unbeatable Location in New Berlin, WI
Located conveniently at 18540 W National Ave, Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse is easy to find and hard to leave. Its central spot in New Berlin makes it a go-to destination for families, groups, and solo diners. With ample parking and a spacious interior, it’s the perfect setting for everything from a casual lunch to a celebratory dinner.
Mustang Shelly's also hosts private events. Whether it’s a birthday bash, a corporate gathering, or just a fun night out, the accommodating staff ensures your experience is seamless. They’ll even tailor the menu to suit your event, ensuring every guest leaves satisfied.
What Customers Are Saying
Reviews for Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse paint a glowing picture of this beloved spot. Regulars praise the friendly service, which makes every visit feel like a reunion with old friends. First-time diners often remark on the vibrant atmosphere and consistently delicious food.
One reviewer wrote, "The live music was fantastic, and the BBQ ribs were the best I've ever had!" Another shared, "Mustang Shelly's is my new go-to spot in New Berlin—great food, great drinks, and great vibes!"
A Community Favorite That Keeps Giving Back
Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse isn't just a place to eat; it's a cornerstone of the New Berlin community. From hosting charity events to supporting local musicians, they continually give back to the area they call home. This dedication to fostering connections has only deepened their popularity over the years.
For those who appreciate a meal served with a side of community spirit, Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse hits the mark every time.
Taco Thursday (10-31-24) was just frickin awesome! Delicious Tacos, fast service and very reasonable prices.My server was dressed as (Wednesday) for Halloween. She was very my personable,funny and downright just fun to interact with! My only regret is that I haven't gone Mustang Shelly's for Tacos before. Five Thursday's left and I plan on going to all of them!